Understanding Sports Card Grading: PSA vs Beckett Complete Guide

Published: January 7, 2026 | Reading Time: 11 minutes

Card grading is essential for serious collectors. Understanding PSA grading, Beckett grading, and card condition helps you make informed decisions about your collection and maximize value.

What is Card Grading?

Sports card grading is the process of having a professional service evaluate your card's card condition and assign it a numerical grade. Graded cards are sealed in protective cases with the grade displayed, providing authentication and condition verification.

Major Card Grading Companies

PSA Grading (Professional Sports Authenticator)

PSA grading is the most recognized card grading service. Founded in 1991, PSA has graded millions of cards and is considered the industry standard for sports card grading.

PSA grading scale: 1-10, with 10 being "Gem Mint"

• PSA 10: Perfect card, no flaws visible
• PSA 9: Mint condition, minor imperfections
• PSA 8: Near Mint, slight wear
• PSA 7: Very Good, noticeable wear
• PSA 6 and below: Various levels of wear and damage

Beckett Grading (BGS)

Beckett grading uses a similar scale but provides sub-grades for corners, edges, surfaces, and centering. Beckett grading is known for stricter standards, making high Beckett grading scores particularly valuable.

Beckett grading features:

• Sub-grades for different card aspects
• Black Label 10 (perfect in all categories)
• Gold Label 9.5
• Standard numerical grades

Card Condition: What Graders Look For

Professional card grading evaluates several aspects of card condition:

Centering

How well-centered the image is on the card. Perfect card condition requires 50/50 centering.

Corners

Sharp, crisp corners are essential for high card grading scores. Any rounding or damage lowers the card condition grade.

Edges

Clean, smooth edges without chipping or wear indicate good card condition.

Surface

The card surface should be free of scratches, print defects, or other imperfections for top card grading.

PSA Grading vs Beckett Grading: Which to Choose?

Choosing between PSA grading and Beckett grading depends on your goals:

Choose PSA Grading If:

• You want the most recognized card grading service
• You're selling cards (PSA commands higher resale values)
• You prefer simpler grading without sub-grades
• You want faster turnaround times

Choose Beckett Grading If:

• You want detailed sub-grades for card condition
• You prefer stricter card grading standards
• You're collecting modern cards (BGS is popular for newer cards)
• You want the Black Label 10 designation

How Card Grading Affects Value

Graded cards typically command higher prices than raw cards. Here's how card grading impacts value:

• PSA 10: Can be 5-10x the value of a raw card
• PSA 9: Often 2-3x raw card value
• PSA 8: Slightly above raw card value
• PSA 7 and below: May be less than raw card value

Understanding card condition and card grading helps you make smart buying and selling decisions.

The Card Grading Process

Here's how sports card grading works:

1. Submit Your Card: Send cards to PSA grading or Beckett grading service
2. Authentication: Service verifies card authenticity
3. Condition Evaluation: Professional graders assess card condition
4. Grading: Card receives numerical grade
5. Encapsulation: Graded cards are sealed in protective case
6. Return: Card is returned with grade displayed

Card Grading Costs

Card grading costs vary by service and turnaround time:

• PSA grading: $15-$300+ depending on value and speed
• Beckett grading: $15-$250+ depending on service level
• Faster turnaround = higher cost
• Bulk submissions often get discounts

When to Grade Cards

Not all cards benefit from card grading. Consider PSA grading or Beckett grading for:

• High-value cards ($100+)
• Rookie cards of star players
• Cards in excellent card condition
• Cards you plan to sell
• Vintage cards in good condition

Card Condition Self-Assessment

Before sending for card grading, assess card condition yourself:

• Examine under good lighting
• Check corners, edges, and surface
• Compare to online examples of graded cards
• Use magnification if needed

If card condition is poor, card grading may not be worth the cost.

Conclusion

Understanding card grading, PSA grading, Beckett grading, and card condition is essential for serious collectors. Graded cards provide authentication, protection, and often higher values.

Whether you choose PSA grading or Beckett grading, proper card condition assessment helps you make informed decisions about your collection.

← Back to Blog