Trading Card Marketplaces: eBay vs COMC vs PWCC Comparison 2026

Published: January 17, 2026 | Reading Time: 13 minutes

Choosing the right trading card marketplace is crucial for buying and selling sports cards. Each platform offers unique advantages and disadvantages. This comprehensive comparison of eBay, COMC, and PWCC will help you decide which card marketplace works best for your needs.

eBay: The Largest Marketplace

eBay is the world's largest trading card marketplace, with millions of cards listed daily.

Pros of eBay

• Massive Selection: Millions of cards available
• Competitive Prices: Auction format often yields deals
• Buyer Protection: Money-back guarantee for items not as described
• Easy to Use: Simple listing and buying process
• Global Reach: Access to international sellers
• Mobile App: Easy buying and selling on the go

Cons of eBay

• High Fees: 10-13% final value fees plus PayPal fees
• Competition: Harder to stand out among millions of listings
• Scams: Need to be vigilant about fake cards
• Shipping Hassles: Must handle shipping yourself
• Time Consuming: Creating listings takes time

Best For

eBay is ideal for:

• Buyers looking for specific cards
• Sellers with diverse inventories
• Auctions and rare cards
• International transactions

COMC (Check Out My Cards): Consignment Service

COMC is a unique trading card marketplace that handles storage, listing, and shipping for sellers.

Pros of COMC

• No Shipping Hassles: COMC handles all shipping
• Bulk Listing: Easy to list many cards at once
• Storage Service: Cards stored securely at COMC
• Combined Shipping: Buy multiple cards, ship once
• Lower Fees: Typically 10% commission
• Professional Photos: COMC takes photos for you

Cons of COMC

• Processing Time: Cards take time to be listed
• Less Control: Can't adjust prices instantly
• Smaller Audience: Less traffic than eBay
• Storage Fees: Monthly fees for stored cards
• Limited Interaction: Less direct seller-buyer contact

Best For

COMC is ideal for:

• Sellers with large inventories
• Those who want hands-off selling
• Buyers who want to combine purchases
• Common cards and sets

PWCC (Probstein123): Premium Auctions

PWCC is a premium trading card marketplace specializing in high-end cards and auctions.

Pros of PWCC

• Premium Cards: Focus on high-value, graded cards
• Expert Curation: Only quality cards accepted
• Strong Prices: Often achieves higher prices
• Professional Service: Handles everything professionally
• Reputation: Trusted name in the hobby
• Graded Focus: Specializes in PSA/BGS cards

Cons of PWCC

• High Fees: 20% commission plus fees
• Selective: Not all cards accepted
• Minimum Values: Focuses on higher-value cards
• Less Control: Auction format limits control
• Longer Process: Auctions take time

Best For

PWCC is ideal for:

• High-value graded cards
• Sellers wanting maximum prices
• Vintage and rare cards
• Investment-grade cards

Comparison Table

Feature	eBay	COMC	PWCC
Fees	10-13%	10%	20%+
Selection	Millions	Hundreds of thousands	Thousands (premium)
Best For	All cards	Common cards	High-end cards
Shipping	You handle	COMC handles	PWCC handles

Using Card Scanner Apps at Marketplaces

When buying on trading card marketplaces, use sports card scanner apps to:

• Verify card authenticity
• Check current market values
• Compare prices across platforms
• Identify card variations
• Research card history

Tips for Buying on Marketplaces

• Research sellers' feedback ratings
• Examine photos carefully
• Read item descriptions thoroughly
• Compare prices across platforms
• Use card scanner apps to verify values
• Ask questions before buying

Tips for Selling on Marketplaces

• Take clear, well-lit photos
• Describe condition accurately
• Research current market values
• Price competitively
• Ship securely and promptly
• Communicate with buyers

Conclusion

Each trading card marketplace has its strengths. eBay offers the largest selection, COMC provides convenience, and PWCC focuses on premium cards. Choose the platform that best fits your needs, and always use card scanner apps to verify values and authenticity.

For more information, see our guides on Selling Cards Online and Card Values.